Fan Mail
April 8th, 2009 § 5 Comments
A “Dr. Muhsir al-Mutawakil” from the “Coalition Against Palestinian War Crimes” sends me the following mail (IP address: 72.1.195.4). There is no online record of a “Muhsir al-Mutawakil” anywhere, nor of a so-called “Coalition against Palestinian War Crimes” existing. Gilad Atzmon has received the exact same letter according to this email (see half-way down) circulated on the E-Palestine yahoogroups list. His “books”? They don’t exist either. Over at Richard Bartholomew’s blog there is info that suggests that this fellow is a serial hoaxer (cheers Tom). Incidentally, over the past couple of months we have seen many comments posted under stolen identities by Zion’s cyber-warriors. We are now keeping an eye on suspect IPs.
Its amusing to see the desperate and ineffectual lengths to which Zio-hacks will sink. Embedded comments in grey added by Ann.
Murderous Palestinian Arabs Do Not Deserve Sympathy
To: Muhammad Idrees Ahmad
Reliable sources at Strathclyde University have informed my organization that you are still committed to waging a propaganda war against the holy [!] state of Israel and its holy [self-appointed as God's chosen] Jewish people.
A review by our Investigations Department of the evidence submitted in your dossier clearly reveals that the views and activities you are promoting constitute encouragement of terrorism and therefore you bear considerable responsibility [forget israel's crimes] for the internecine massacres being conducted by Palestinian Arabs [no massacres there, only israeli ones] against each other as well as for the war with Israel.
This is because your execrable rantings [which have evidently excited your considerable interest] are broadcast on the Internet and swallowed whole by impressionable Palestinians [that's right, infantilise the whole Palestinian population, apparently they can't think for themselves, unlike the "holy" israeli population wholly committing atrocities and rendering Palestine hole-y].
The hasbara propaganda continues in all its hackneyed fiction:
I want you to realize that the Fatah-Hamas civil war is a continuation of the 1970 Nakba in Jordan when the Hashemite ruler entered the refugee camps and slaughtered mercilessly 20,000 Palestinian Arabs.
This was the largest horrific massacre of the Palestinians in history. You are afraid to mention this savagery publicly for fear you will be destroyed. [What rubbish, (yawn)]
The current nakba and Gaza war is the inevitable result of your (and others like you) hatred of holy Israel. Your constant concocting of propaganda stories against the Jewish state has created a climate of brutal aggression in the Palestinian territories, spurring on untold numbers of terrorist atrocities against Jews and Christians in the Holy Land. [Goodness! I caused all that! What omnipotent powers must I have! The hasbara propaganda is all yours. As for Palestinian suffering, the causality is all courtesy the apartheid state for which you excuse their atrocities and warcrimes. Shame on you.] You have fabricated a conspiracy by America and Israel that is responsible for the Gaza war [we have done no such thing] instead of laying the blame at the feet of the brutal Palestinian Arabs themselves. Their Hamas-ruled Gaza is nothing but a dysfunctional colonial outpost of imperialist Iran. (yawn)
The rest does not even bear commenting on, its so poor quality:
Therefore, you have made the Palestinian Arabs into a violent people (just like the Iraqis) who, unfortunately, are not interested in negotiating peace. They have been solely interested in murdering every Jew and Christian in the Holy Land.
Having recently returned from Samaria and Gaza, our members have seen with their own eyes how the Palestinian Arabs savagely desecrated and demolished the Greek Orthodox and Catholic churches there and burnt down the YMCAs in Qalqilya and Gaza City because their imams and intellectuals incited them against Pope Benedict. Now they are raping Catholic nuns in Gaza City and shooting Baptists in their bookstores there. Afterwards, they slaughter each other’s old men, innocent women and children in hospitals, on the beaches and in apartment buildings. Such is the result of mad violence.
You should be taking an active role in dismantling the Palestinian hate structure that provides the only solution for Jew and Arab to live together on the basis of peace, equality and harmony. The model for this are the 500,000 Jews and Christians who lived in blessed symbiosis in the Hijaz with their Arab neighbours for five centuries before Islam arrived. In fact, dozens of Arab tribes converted to Judaism and Christianity at that time.
While it is trite, as some journalists note, that every nation requires a major civil war before it is incarnated as a state, it is true that fanatic Arabs like you that soak the Palestinian Arab minds with violence and dreams of violence are directly responsible for such nakbas.
However, it is not too late for you to make amends. Tell the Palestinian Arabs, in Gaza especially, that all these years you and similar dysfunctional Arabs were wrong about Israel. Tell them the Koran teaches that the Holy Land belongs to the Jews. Tell them if they worship violence, Allah will make them drunk with violence and they will turn on each other and slaughter each other without mercy until all their streets and fields overflow with blood.
Everyone knows that the civil war between Fatah and Hamas and the Gaza war against Hamas came about due to Divine intervention. It is a Divine punishment of the Palestinian Arab people until they eschew terrorism and leave the heartland of Judaism which they stole in 637 A.D.. Their colonial settler project in Palestine must now come to an end. It has existed up till now because the Palestinian invaders who had arrived on the backs of the imperialist Arab powers led by Caliph Umar stole the land of Israel from the indigenous Jews living there.
This theft of Jewish land was repeated in 1922 when the Arab settler colonialists gained control of nearly four-fifths of Palestine in collusion with the British imperialists and renamed it “Trans-Jordan.”
This was all revealed in a speech by the Mufti Haj Amin al-Husseini in 1939 in a conference with his Nazi friends in Berlin.
If you fail to do this, the senseless shedding of Palestinian Arab blood will be on your head for eternity and no one will care whether their cause was just.
Note: Dr. al-Mutawakil is a Palestinian native of Rafah, Gaza. In 1991, his parents were tortured to death by the Hamas gang in Gaza. In 1996, he converted to Judaism.
* Dr. Muhsir al-Mutawakil
CEO, Coalition Against Palestinian War Crimes
London, England
* Author:
A Decade of Hamas Concentration Camps in Gaza
Palestinian Arab Fundamentalism vs. Human Rights
The Hamas War Against Christians
Who Stole the Land of Israel?
Why do the anti-Zionists feel that a thousand-year old claim by Arabs who were never ruled by Palestinian Arabs has legitimacy, while a 1,900-year claim by Jews to the land should be rejected as absurd?
So let us see if we have this straight. The anti-Zionists claim that the Jews have no right to the land of Israel because before Israel was re-created in 1948, it had been almost 1,900 years since the last time that the Jews exercised sovereignty over the Land of Israel. And the anti-Zionists claim that it is absurd to argue that anyone still has rights to land that was last governed with sovereignty 1,900 years ago.
And on what basis do they argue that the Arabs have some legitimate claim to these same lands? On the basis of the claim that the Arabs last exercised sovereignty over that land 1,000 years ago.
Are you all with me? 1,900 year-old-claims are inadmissible. Thousand-year-old claims trump them and are indisputable.
Now let us emphasize that even the thousand-year-old Arab claim is not the same thing as a claim on behalf of Palestinian [sic] Arabs. After all, the last time that Palestinian Arabs held sovereignty over the lands of “Palestine” was … never. There has never been a Palestinian Arab state in Palestine. Ever.
It is true that Arabs once exercised sovereignty over parts or all of historic Palestine. There were small Arab kingdoms in the south of “Palestine” already in late Biblical days, and they were important military and political allies of the Jews, who exercised sovereignty back then in the Land of Israel. After the rise of Islam, historic “Palestine” was indeed part of a larger Arab kingdom or caliphate. But that ended in 1071 CE, when Palestine came under the rule of the Suljuk Turks. That was the last time Palestine had an Arab ruler. After that, it was always ruled by a long series of Ottomans, Mamluks, other Turks, Crusaders, British, and — briefly — French. And in any case, why does the fact that Palestine once belonged to a larger Arab empire make it any more “Arab” than the fact that it also was once part of larger Roman, Greek, Persian, Turkish, or British empires? Now it is true that historic Palestine probably once had a population majority who were Arabs, but today it has a population majority who are Jews. So if population majorities are what determine legitimacy of sovereignty, Israel is at least as legitimate as any other country.
So why exactly do the anti-Zionists claim that a thousand-year old claim by Arabs who were never ruled by Palestinian Arabs has legitimacy, while a 1,900-year claim by Jews to the land should be rejected as absurd, even though the United Nations granted Israel sovereignty in 1947? The anti-Zionists say it is because the thousand-year-old Arab claim is more recent than the older Jewish claim. But if national claims to lands become more legitimate when they are more recent, then surely the most legitimate of all is that of the Jews of Israel to the lands of Israel, because it is the most recent!
The other claim by the anti-Zionists is that Jews have no rights to the lands of Israel (historic Palestine) because they moved there from some other places. Now never mind that there was actually always a Jewish minority living in the lands of Israel even when it was under the sovereignty of Romans, Greeks, Arabs, Crusaders, Turks or British. Does the fact that Jews moved to the land of Israel from other places disqualify them from exercising sovereignty there? The claim would be absurd enough even if we were to ignore that fact that most “Palestinian Arabs” also moved to Palestine from neighboring countries, starting in the late nineteenth century. But more generally, does the fact that a people moves from one locality to another deprive it of its claims to legitimate sovereignty in its new abode? Does this fact necessitate the conclusion that they need to pack up and leave, as the anti-Zionists insist?
If it does, then it goes without saying that the Americans and Canadians must lead the way and show the Israelis the light, by returning all lands that they seized from the Indians and the Mexicans to their original owners and going back to whence they came. For that matter, the Mexicans of Spanish ancestry also need to leave. The Anglo-Saxons, meaning the English, will be invited to turn the British Isles over to their rightful original Celtic and Druid owners, while they return to their own ancestral Saxon homeland in northern Germany and Denmark. The Danes of course will be asked to move aside, in fact to move back to their Norwegian and Swedish homelands, to make room for the returning Anglo-Saxons.
But that is just a beginning. The Spanish will be called upon to leave the Iberian Peninsula that they wrongfully occupy, and return it to the Celtiberians. Similarly the Portuguese occupiers will leave their lands and return them to the Lusitanians. The Magyars will go back where they came from and leave Hungary to its true owners. The Australians and New Zealanders obviously will have to end their occupations of lands that do not belong to them. The Thais will leave Thailand. The Bulgarians will return to their Volga homeland and abandon occupied Bulgaria. Anyone speaking Spanish will be expected to end his or her forced occupation of Latin America. It goes without saying that the French will lose almost all their lands to their rightful owners. The Turks will go back to Mongolia and leave Anatolia altogether, returning it to the Greeks. The Germans will go back to Gotland. The Italians will return the boot to the Etruscans and Greeks.
Ah, but that leaves the Arabs. First, all of northern Africa, from Mauritania to Egypt and Sudan, will have to be immediately abandoned by the illegal Arab occupiers and squatters, and returned to their lawful original Berber, Punic, Greek, and Vandal owners. Occupied Syria and Lebanon must be released at once from the cruel occupation of the Arab imperialist aggressors. Iraq must be returned to the Assyrians and Chaldeans. Southern Arabia must be returned to the Abyssinians. The Arabs may retain control of the central portion of the Arabian Peninsula as their homeland. But not the oil fields.
Oh, and the Palestinian infiltrators, usurpers and squatters will of course have to return the lands they are illegally and wrongfully occupying, turning them over to their legal and rightful owners, which would of course be the Jews!
I think you have got hold of the wrong end of the stick.
The Palestinians want equal rights for all the People in the region, not a history lesson , and certainly not cheap apologies for wanton colonialism.
OH that was some history lesson but like very thing Zionist its RETARDED!
So according to you it Palestinians only moved to Palestine 1000 years ago…wait then why was it called Palestine, oh I know they must have replaced all the sign boards. Please do not count rest of us as utterly moronic and retarded as your self, Kenanites were the original inhabitants of that land which are now called Palestinians and there lands were destroyed by the invading jewsih tribes who went to great lengths to trying eradicate them then just like now!
So Just shut up IDIOT!
Compromise is the name of the game. If only people could set aside their own memories and philosophical differences to create a new philosophy so that all could live in peace. I know, only God, Allah, or Jehovah can create a new world. But, instead he put us all here.
Publisher’s Note: Our author had it right in 1987, but could not be published because they said the events he predicted could not possibly happen. Well, they did, and we finally published him when we discovered the manuscript. Mr. Spirko tells us that President Obama’s motive for trying the peace initiative is that this is probably the last chance for peace in the Middle East before a catastrophic World War III event takes place. Spirko says, “It is never too late for peace.” Most of the ideas being used at Annapolis and the continuing peace talks are from Spirko’s book.
(Jpeg book cover available at Barnesandnoble.com, Borders.com or Amazon.com)
SAN FRANCISCO – THE PALESTINE CONSPIRACY, a genre spy-thriller by Robert Spirko, was fourth on the best-seller list at Atlasbooks, Inc., a national book distributor. Ingram Books is the worldwide distributor.
Spirko, a financial and geo-political analyst who has given his advice to the National Security Council, turned his attention to the Middle East in 1987, after discovering several common elements related to the Middle East question. He wrote down his analysis, and when he was finished, he not only had a solution to the quagmire, he had a story to tell. THE PALESTINE CONSPIRACY foreshadowed the Persian Gulf War by three years, and the resultant Iraq War followed by the Sept. 11 attack.
“Everyone tells me there will never be peace in the Middle East, but I tell them they are wrong. Israel and Egypt have had a peace treaty for 29 years. Jordan and Israel signed a peace agreement 14 years ago. A Palestinian State can be created. It can be done and it will be done,” Spirko reiterates. “Twenty-nine years of peace is better than 29 years of war.”
Spirko has given his advice over the years to the National Security Council including the 2000 Camp David Peace Talks under President Bill Clinton.
“We’re not talking about a serpent-tongued, false prophet who will negotiate this peace between Israel and the Islamists, it will be done by a U.S. president and those parties involved in the peace process who will finally achieve it through hard work, tough compromises, and by making specific decisions fair to both sides to agree to end the violence once-and-for-all – by those leaders who want a future for their children,” Spirko says.
“Besides, Israel wants a Palestinian state now, too.”
“In the end, both sides need to address security concerns, reparations and building moral and economic trust. We all report to the same God, whether we call him God, Jehovah or Allah,” he says.
Spirko’s key ideas at the 2000 Camp David Peace Talks were to make Jerusalem the simultaneous capital of both Israel and a Palestinian state with congruent borders – one precisely overlapping the other – using two maps – one for the Palestinian state and one for Israel. The city would become an international, undivided open city for people of all religions to visit and the municipality would be governed by a city council of equal Palestinians and Jews with God, Allah or Jehovah as the central sovereign. The Knesset and Palestinian authority would then govern their respective states from that dual capital. In effect, Jerusalem would become a governing district much like the District of Columbia in Washington, D. C. This idea won traction at the 2000 Camp David Peace Talks and was virtually agreed upon, but where the talks broke down and failed was when both sides capitulated to pressures from their own political factions over right of return and reparations. Mr. Spirko has an idea to solve that problem also.
Spirko’s book is available though area book stores or on the web at Barnesandnoble.com, Borders.com and Amazon.com. The novel is a mass market paperback produced by Olive Grove Publishers, and can be purchased at area bookstores through Ingram Book Group, New Leaf Distribution, and Baker and Taylor, priced at $14.99, ISBN 0-9752508-0-9. THE PALESTINE CONSPIRACY can also be ordered on the web at http://www.atlasbooks.com, or email orders from: order@bookmasters.com, or from Barnes & Nobles, Border’s, Dalton’s, efollett.com & Follett bookstores at colleges and universities, WaldenBooks, Amazon.com, Walmart.com, Target.com and other popular retail bookstores. Or, readers and store managers can call 1-800-BOOKLOG, or 800-247-6553 direct, to order.
-30-
I have recently become associated with the Menahem and Bessie Olshansky International Centre for the Eradication of Israelophobia. Your reprint of the remarks by Dr. Muhsir al-Mutawakil, who is a senior fellow at the Institute, was timely as it refutes the Palestinian fictionalized narrative about their “oppression” by the Jews. Your own running commentary was of a sneering nature, thus unhelpful from an intellectual and historic standpoint. The days of the might of the Palestine lobby are coming to an end. in its place, Christians and Jews and kurds will reclaims their legitimate homelands in the Middle east which the Palestinians and their brother Arab Muslims stole.
Onesime de Girardin
Secretaire-General