J Street’s Really Big Problem

J Street’s problem isn’t what it is—it’s what it isn’t.

In a February 16, 2010 address to the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations, Israeli Deputy Foreign Minister Danny Ayalon inadvertently revealed his government’s core problem with the new American lobbying organization J Street.

Ayalon and other members of the Israeli government boycotted a J Street delegation shepherding members of the US Congress through Israel this week.  Ayalon strongly condemned J Street: “They don’t present themselves as what they really are.  They should not call themselves pro-Israeli.” J Street’s Jeremy Ben-Ami attributes this “spat” to an “inability of some in Israel and in the US to distinguish between criticism or disagreement with Israeli policy and outright hostility to the state itself.”  J Street positions itself as a “pro-peace” and “pro-Israel” alternative to the American Israel Public Affairs Committee.

However the Israeli government’s core problem with J-Street is far more profound.  J Street’s main competition, AIPAC, was actually created by a former employee of the Israeli Ministry of Foreign Affairs, Isaiah L. Kenen, who set the existing standard for coordinating AIPAC’s lobbying with the needs of the Israeli government while repeatedly dodging DOJ foreign agent registration orders.  The Conference of Presidents, which organizes AIPAC’s executive committee, actually works out of the same New York office as the World Zionist Organization – American Section (which itself is a shell corporation set up in the US after the Jewish Agency’s American Section, another quasi arm of the Israeli government, was shut down as a foreign agent in the early 1970’s ).

J Street’s biggest problem is what they really are not—unregistered foreign agents of the Israeli government.  Until J-Street starts violating the spirit (and letter) of the 1938 Foreign Agents Registration Act like the competition, it is unlikely to get any love from the Israeli government.

One thought on “J Street’s Really Big Problem”

  1. Grant Smith knows what he is talking about since he has done the major research and writing about what has been the successful, and largely ignored, efforts of what is essentially an arm of the Israeli government, namely AIPAC, from being obliged to register as an agency of a foreign government, on the basis that it is run by Jewish Americans and not Jewish Israelis. That both happen to salute the same flag (and it is NOT the stars and stripes), as is evident from AIPAC’s checkered history, is something that should disturb every American, regardless of their background.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s